Did Bob Dylan plagiarise his Nobel speech?

Bob Dylan will have plagiarised his Nobel Prize lecture from SparkNotes, an internet model of CliffsNotes, it has been claimed.

Slate Magazine uncovered similarities between the website’s entry on Moby-Dick and Dylan’s speech, wherein he discussed the three books that had the most important influence on his career.

The investigation used to be brought about by the discovery that the musician had quoted a passage which does No Longer seem in any present variations of Herman Melville’s novel.

Dylan quoted a Quaker priest who, in the aftermath of a storm at sea, tells every other persona: “Some men who obtain accidents are ended in God, others are led to bitterness.”

Creator Ben Greenman observed the line did not appear in Melville’s novel, suggesting Dylan may have misremembered the e book.

On The Other Hand, Slate revealed that SparkNotes used similar phrasing, describing the preacher as “any individual whose trials have led him toward God reasonably than bitterness”.

It then stated 19 additional similarities between Dylan’s description of Moby-Dick and the summary on SparkNotes, together with:

Dylan: “There’s a crazy prophet, Gabriel, on One Of The Vital vessels, and he predicts Ahab’s doom.”

SparkNotes: “Some Of The ships … consists of Gabriel, a crazed prophet who predicts doom.”

Dylan: “Captain Boomer – he lost an arm to Moby. However… he’s satisfied to have survived. He cannot accept Ahab’s lust for vengeance.”

SparkNotes: “Captain Boomer has misplaced an arm in an come across with Moby Dick… Boomer, happy simply to have survived his encounter, can not take note Ahab’s lust for vengeance.”

Dylan: “He calls Moby the emperor, sees him because the embodiment of evil.”

SparkNotes: “He sees this whale as the embodiment of evil.”

In each of those cases, the key phrases (“predicts doom”; “lust for vengeance”; “embodiment of evil”) don’t appear in Melville’s authentic text.

Representatives for Dylan and the Nobel Prize Committee have yet to respond to a request for comment.

Media playback is unsupported in your software

The musician received the the Nobel Prize for literature in October and had except 10 June to ship his lecture or forfeit the prize money of 8m krona ($900,000, £727,000).

He delivered the speech within the type of a beat poem, recited over a meandering piano, just ahead of the closing date on Four June – elevating the scrumptious prospect that, like every youngster in a band, he cribbed his homework off the web in a last-minute panic.

However this is not the primary time Dylan has been accused of copying any person else’s work.

He poached some stanzas from 19th-Century Confederate poet Henry Timrod for Modern Instances; whereas one of the crucial lyrics on his 2001 album Love and Theft were allegedly according to Junichi Saga’s ebook Confessions of a Yakuza.

‘Grasp thief’

In June 2009, Christie’s of latest York auctioned one among his earliest handwritten poems, Little Chum, which had been submitted to his summer time camp newspaper in 1957.

However eagle-eyed historians spotted that the poem used to be a thinly-veiled rewrite of a Hank Snow track, also referred to as Little Chum.

And, previous this year, a British photographer spotted an uncanny similarity between his shot of Blackpool Pier and one in all Dylan’s artwork, which purports to indicate Norfolk, Virginia.

The musician has defended his interpolation of folks’s work as being part of the people tradition, paying homage to the artists who got here sooner than, and re-contextualising their work for a Up To Date audience.

“If I was once a Master thief, in all probability I Might rob them,” he sang on Positively 4th Side Road; whereas, in a 2012 interview with Rolling Stone Journal, he defended himself in opposition to accusations of plagiarism on Love and Theft.

“I’m working within my art kind,” he said. “It’s that straightforward. I work throughout the ideas and limitations of it. There are authoritarian figures that may provide an explanation for that kind of art type higher to you than I Will Be Able To. It’s referred to as songwriting. It has to do with melody and rhythm, after which after that, anything goes.

“You Are Making the whole thing yours. We All do it.”

Follow us on Facebook, on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, or on Instagram at bbcnewsents. In Case You Have a narrative advice email leisure.News@bbc.co.uk.

Let’s block advertisements! (Why?)

Comments are closed.